A Journey Through "Treasure Mountain": A Disappointment in the Sackett Saga
When I picked up Treasure Mountain by Louis L’Amour, I was excited to dive back into the wild expanse of the American West with the Sacketts—characters I’ve come to love for their grit and adventurous spirit. It’s always fascinating to see where L’Amour will take us, and I had high hopes for a thrilling escape filled with Western charm and rich storytelling. However, what unfolded was a surprisingly lackluster narrative that left me feeling more frustrated than fulfilled.
At its core, Treasure Mountain attempts to weave a tale of family legacy and adventure as Orrin and Tell Sackett embark on a quest to uncover the truth about their father’s death—specifically, the buried gold believed to be hidden in Southern Colorado. However, this compelling premise falters as a significant portion of the story takes us to New Orleans, a setting that feels utterly disconnected from the rugged landscapes we associate with the Sacketts. This deviation felt jarring, and it made me wonder: what happened to the quintessential Western adventures that L’Amour used to masterfully create?
One major character, labeled only as "the Tinker," serves as a prime example of a frustrating narrative choice. With a name so vague, this character felt faceless and unmemorable, rendering an important presence in the plot lackluster. Then there’s Nell Trelawney, who initially seemed poised to bring a spark of romance to the tale. Instead, she remained an underdeveloped figure, serving as mere window-dressing rather than a dynamic participant. The chemistry between her and Tell Sackett never ignited, leaving me longing for the vibrant relationships that are hallmarks of L’Amour’s work.
What perhaps disturbs me most is the choice of narrative style. The book alternates between first-person and third-person perspectives in a way that felt clumsy. I often found myself puzzled: Is the first-person narrator documenting their adventure in a diary? Or is this some memoir-like dictation? This inconsistency detracted from my immersion in the story and left me more puzzled than engaged.
There are fleeting moments of L’Amour’s signature sarcasm and wit, particularly during a notable gunfight scene, where Tell’s commentary provides a rising pulse to the plot. Yet, these moments alone can’t carry an entire narrative. The story grapples with questions of whether Pa Sackett is still alive and whether Tell will uncover the truth, but the resolution lacked clarity and left me unsatisfied.
As I reflect on Treasure Mountain, I can’t help but feel a sense of disappointment. If L’Amour ever chooses to revisit the character of Nell Trelawney, I’d venture to say that such a tale would likely be much more captivating than this installment. For those deeply invested in the Sackett saga, this novel might feel less like an adventure and more like a detour.
In conclusion, if you’re a die-hard fan yearning for classic L’Amour Westerns, you may find this book falls short of expectations. However, if you’re looking for a lighter read with a touch of exploration into family dynamics, you might still find value here. For me, this journey through Treasure Mountain was less a treasure hunt and more of a reminder that even cherished authors can misfire.
Discover more about Treasure Mountain (The Sacketts, #15) on GoodReads >>
