Reflecting on Cities of the Plain: A Journey Through Borders and Bonds
There’s something captivating about Cormac McCarthy’s writing that pulls you in like a quiet night beneath vast, starry skies. I’ve long been enchanted by the world he conjures in Cities of the Plain, the third installment of his Border Trilogy. The layered complexity of the human experience, woven together with raw emotion and stunning prose, feels as real as the sunburnt earth from which his characters emerge. Having followed John Grady Cole from All the Pretty Horses and Billy Parham from The Crossing, I was eager to see how their paths intertwined in this final chapter.
At the heart of this novel, McCarthy invites us into a world rich with themes of love, loss, and existential conflict. Set against the backdrop of a rapidly changing America in 1952, we find John Grady and Billy, two young men teetering on the brink of adulthood yet grounded by the heartaches of their pasts. Both men share an unbreakable bond forged through experiences that few can understand, and their reunion amidst the rustic charm of a Texas ranch brings forth a deep sense of nostalgia and melancholy.
John, a cowboy with a gentle spirit, finds himself torn between his love for Magdalena, a young prostitute with a troubled past, and the harsh realities of the lives they lead. McCarthy deftly illustrates this dynamic not just as a tale of romance but as a poignant desire for redemption—a yearning to rescue someone from the precipice of despair. The relationship is imbued with a sense of tragic beauty, underscoring that the most profound connections often stem from shared suffering.
The writing style in Cities of the Plain is signature McCarthy: dense yet poetic, with a rhythm that feels almost musical. Pacing balances the serene moments with bursts of tension, notably in the climactic confrontation with Eduardo, Magdalena’s owner. This tension is palpable and leaves the reader breathless, eagerly flipping pages while grappling with the deeper implications of human greed, violence, and survival. As McCarthy asserts through his characters, "we are what we are," prompting a reflection on the limits of personal agency amidst predestined circumstances.
The beautifully vivid imagery woven through McCarthy’s prose brought entire landscapes to life. I found myself enthralled by the evocative description of the borderlands—the arid deserts, the looming presence of the missile base, and the darker underbelly of a city’s night. Such vivid descriptions create an almost tactile experience, allowing readers to feel the weight of the world upon the characters’ shoulders.
One of the quotes that resonated with me personally spoke to the existential dilemma of human experience: “This life you give so much importance to is not your creation… it has been imposed upon the void since the world began.” It’s a chilling reminder of the randomness of existence and the insignificance of our struggles compared to the vast tapestry of time and fate.
Cities of the Plain is not merely a Western. It transcends genre, appealing to anyone curious about the interplay of morality, friendship, and love against the backdrop of an unforgiving landscape. If you’ve traversed McCarthy’s world before, this novel offers closure and contemplation that lingers long after the last page is turned.
For those who appreciate a story steeped in realism and existential contemplation, I wholeheartedly recommend diving into this masterpiece. It’s a reminder of the enduring power of storytelling and the ever-present shadow of our pasts, reminding us that no matter how far we roam, the ties that bind us often lead us back home.
Discover more about Cities of the Plain (The Border Trilogy, #3) on GoodReads >>
