A Journey Through Shame and Pride: A Review of Stolen Pride: Loss, Shame, and the Rise of the Right
I was drawn to Stolen Pride: Loss, Shame, and the Rise of the Right by Nancy Isenberg not just by its compelling title but by a desire to understand the currents of shame and pride that fuel our contemporary political landscape. In our increasingly polarized society, what does it mean to experience pride in one’s identity amidst feelings of loss and blame? Each page of Isenberg’s book felt like a deeper dive into not just the mechanics of political strategy, but also into the human heart—a space we often overlook in discussions of “the other side.”
At its core, Stolen Pride explores the interplay of identity, culture, and the pervasive shame that underpins extremist politics. The stories of Ruth Mullins, John Rosenberg, and Dr. Budgy encapsulate the varied, painful experiences that people face around issues of race, religion, and displacement. Isenberg deftly interweaves these narratives, reflecting on how their backgrounds—stemming from the United States, India, and Germany—shape their encounters with caste systems and societal hierarchies. It’s on page 77 where the author profoundly captures this, stating that “every form of caste has historically been built on shame,” a point that resonated deeply with my understanding of societal constructs.
Isenberg’s writing style shines in its clarity and depth. She deftly balances academic rigor with a narrative accessibility that makes heavy themes digestible for a wider audience. The pacing allowed for moments of reflection, especially when articulating the concept of the “deep story” that undergirds political ideologies—an idea I found particularly impactful. The way she presents a figure “patiently waiting in line,” feeling threatened by perceived line-cutters, encapsulates a powerful metaphor for resentment felt by many; it had me nodding in recognition.
Among my favorite passages is Isenberg’s examination of Trump’s anti-shame ritual, illustrating how he transforms shame into a weapon of pride. The ritualized dance of provoking, shaming, victimhood, and roaring back is described with both keen observation and a touch of empathy. Her insights into how Trump’s narrative evolves—from loss to the notion of "stolen"—felt like an important lens through which to understand our current political climate. It wasn’t just about the politics of loss; it was about the emotional narratives we weave around them, and her description brought to light how this narrative shift can resonate with so many individuals across our fractured nation.
This book isn’t merely a political treatise; it’s a heartfelt exploration of how personal and collective identities are shaped by shame and pride in communities. I believe it could captivate readers interested in social justice, political science, or human psychology. Isenberg’s exploration into the human experience behind political labels and beliefs is a conversation starter that, at a minimum, will make you reconsider the stories we tell ourselves about each other.
In closing, Stolen Pride left me pondering long after the last page. It’s a deft reminder that politics is not only about policies and power but deeply rooted in our shared human experiences, fraught with emotion and identity. This book will resonate with anyone seeking to understand the complexities of pride in a deeply connected yet divided world. Whether you lean left or right, Isenberg invites us to explore the landscapes of our own biases and to approach this era’s challenges with both humility and courage.
Discover more about Stolen Pride: Loss, Shame, and the Rise of the Right on GoodReads >>
