Stuck: How the Privileged and the Propertied Broke the … – A Deep Dive into Complexity
When I first stumbled upon "Stuck: How the Privileged and the Propertied Broke the…" by Alana Appelbaum, I was captivated by its promise to unravel the layers of America’s pressing socio-economic issues, particularly income inequality and mobility. As someone who finds great joy in dissecting social critiques, I was eager to dive in. However, as I navigated through the pages, I found myself wrestling with the book’s oversimplifications and missed opportunities.
One of the most striking themes of "Stuck" is its argument linking zoning practices directly to declining mobility and rising income inequality. Appelbaum positions zoning as a primary culprit, a thesis that, while provocative, feels reductive. The author seems to overlook that income inequality reached even greater heights during zoning-free periods, a point that hints at the complexity behind such socio-economic phenomena. It appears that Appelbaum misses the larger tapestry of causation—declining union enforcement, manufacturing outsourcing, and even America’s fetishization of the nuclear family all play significant roles.
Moreover, the narrative sometimes lacked grace. Appelbaum’s writing feels like a straight drive down a one-way street, not meandering enough to consider the multifaceted nature of the issues at hand. The comparisons drawn between cities, such as Houston—often cited as a bastion of unregulated development—serve more as anecdotal evidence than as concrete solutions to the conundrum of mobility. I couldn’t help but wonder: how many of Appelbaum’s Atlantic editorial peers would genuinely support unzoned living if it came with the risk of their own neighborhoods changing?
Readers familiar with city planning will find references to historical moments like the creation of zoning laws in Modesto, California, illuminating yet not adequate in solving the larger questions raised. The brief glimpse at Tokyo’s post-1970 housing policies is tantalizing yet frustrating, as the book fails to consider broader global contexts that may offer more effective models for addressing these issues. Old Europe, with its paradox of less mobility yet greater equality, is relegated to a mere footnote rather than explored in depth—an oversight that felt particularly glaring.
Despite these critiques, there are moments where Appelbaum shines, especially in the analysis of how zoning intersects with historical concepts like redlining and restrictive covenants. Yet these insights often feel too few and far between, overshadowed by a narrative that sacrifices nuance for what can only be described as a “Johnny-one-note” approach.
For readers who wish to understand zoning’s role in contemporary socio-economic challenges, "Stuck" might serve as a launching pad, albeit one that leaves much to be desired. If you’re seeking a deep exploration of systemic issues with rich, diverse perspectives—this perhaps isn’t the book for you. However, if you prefer a more simplified narrative that raises some essential questions—then you may find value in Appelbaum’s work.
In conclusion, "Stuck" prompted me to reflect on the intricacies of socio-economic structures in America. Although I had hoped for a richer dialogue, it nonetheless sparked an engaging internal conversation about the interplay between policy and social mobility. I walked away with more questions than answers, which, depending on your perspective, might just be the essence of a good read.
Discover more about Stuck: How the Privileged and the Propertied Broke the … on GoodReads >>
