Book Review: To the Bone by Alena Bruzas
There’s something intriguing about a book that lingers in your mind long after it’s been read, and Alena Bruzas’s To the Bone is exactly that. Having loved her contemporary debut, I was curious to see how she would tackle historical fiction. This tale, set against the backdrop of early colonial America, promised both darkness and depth—a blend that piqued my interest. But as I navigated the complex world of Ellis, the uneducated indentured servant, I found myself both captivated and challenged.
To the Bone unfolds through the eyes of Ellis, a character whose voice is raw and authentic, yet marked by the limitations of her station. The plot delves into themes of socio-economic stratification, cultural tension, and the stark realities of survival. Bruzas does an admirable job of showcasing the harrowing experience of colonial life, particularly through Ellis’s harrowing journey. However, I found myself wishing for more vivid detail about the 1600s landscape, community values, and the intricate social dynamics at play. For those unfamiliar with this era, the minimalist style—so fitting for Ellis’s perspective—may leave some gaps in understanding the broader context.
What struck me most was the tension between the psychological thriller elements and the historical narrative. The more we delve into Ellis’s dark experiences, the more palpable the horror grows, and I appreciated the way Bruzas keeps us on edge. However, there were moments where I felt a second perspective, perhaps from a character like Jane—a more privileged counterpart—could have provided a richer understanding of the social constructs and conflicts. It might have offered readers an opportunity to glean insights into the nuances of the settlers’ interactions with Native Americans, as well as their own community stratifications.
In particular, I found the author’s choice to use “salvages” instead of “savages” provocative. This term choice, thoughtfully explained at the end of the book, raises questions about language and representation. Admittedly, I find myself torn; as a reader with ancestral ties to colonization but not to Native identity, I crave an Indigenous perspective on this choice.
Despite my critiques, I can’t deny that To the Bone is an engaging read, particularly for those who appreciate a quick, thought-provoking journey. The book’s intensity had me flipping pages, and Bruzas’s ability to evoke tension through Ellis’s limited worldview was skillfully executed.
In conclusion, I would recommend this book to readers who thrive on dark, psychological narratives and are intrigued by historical fiction. While it may not fully satisfy those seeking a rich tapestry of world-building, the emotional core and engaging plot hold significant merit. Personally, reading To the Bone offered me not only a thrill but a reflection on the complexity of representation in literature, leaving me eager to see what Bruzas will explore next—perhaps back in the contemporary realm where her voice shined so brightly.
Thank you to Rocky Pond Books and NetGalley for providing this ARC. I’m looking forward to further discussions about this book, especially from readers with diverse perspectives on the themes it presents!
