The Pirate’s Wife: The Remarkable True Story of Sarah Kidd by Diana Wallis Taylor
When I first laid eyes on the title The Pirate’s Wife: The Remarkable True Story of Sarah Kidd, I couldn’t help but feel a rush of intrigue. It’s not every day that a biography about a pirate’s wife catches my attention, particularly in an era where primary source documents are as elusive as the treasures these pirates sought. But there I was, with my curiosity piqued, ready to dive into the world of Sarah Kidd through the lens of Diana Wallis Taylor’s writing.
What I found was a mixed bag of history and conjecture. Taylor does a commendable job of weaving together the threads of Sarah’s life, highlighting her entrepreneurial spirit as a woman in the 17th century—an era where women were seldom recognized as anything other than wives and mothers. Sarah’s marriages and management of properties shine through the historical fog, which is fascinating. Yet, my excitement dimmed upon realizing that the primary sources are sorely lacking. The historical record of Sarah, despite her remarkable life, is threadbare—a single page in the grand story of the age of piracy.
Indeed, the author often takes creative liberties, filling in the blanks with speculative “maybes” and “perhaps,” which left me torn between admiration for her imagination and frustration with the lack of rigorous evidence. What’s interesting, though, is that while Sarah could read, she couldn’t write—leaving the wellspring of detail about her relationship with her husband, Captain William Kidd, tantalizingly shallow. This absence of letters or personal notes only amplifies the mystery surrounding their life together.
Taylor’s narrative style struck me as simple and at times, a bit too juvenile, reminiscent of a YA novel rather than the deep dive into historical intrigue I had hoped for. The pacing felt uneven, and elements like drama and romance were not delivered with the voice they deserved. There were no illustrations or maps to guide the reader through the web of piracy—no pictures of the infamous Captain Kidd or the treasures themselves, which could have made the story more immersive.
One highlight was the book’s discussion of Sarah’s legacy. Taylor evokes a romantic view of Sarah as a pioneer woman, bravely navigating a man’s world—evidence of her entrepreneurial prowess is a breath of fresh air, reminding us that women have always been a formidable force. I did find it curious, however, that the book doesn’t mention the 2007 discovery of the Quedagh Merchant, a significant moment in pirate lore which could have connected readers to tangible history.
In conclusion, The Pirate’s Wife may appeal to those seeking a light-hearted dive into the world of piracy viewed through the lens of a woman’s life, but it might leave history enthusiasts wanting for depth. While Sarah’s story is undeniably compelling, I couldn’t shake the feeling that we only skim the surface of her remarkable life. For me, the reading experience was enlightening yet disappointing—a reminder of how history often leaves us with more questions than answers. If you enjoy tales filled with possibility and romance wrapped in a historical context, this book might just be the ticket. Otherwise, you may wish to seek out a more robust version of the sea-faring tales that have captivated our imaginations for centuries.
Discover more about The Pirate's Wife: The Remarkable True Story of Sarah K… on GoodReads >>
