Engaging Review of 82 Days on Okinawa: One American’s Unforgettable Firsthand Account
As a history buff and avid reader, I was drawn to 82 Days on Okinawa: One American’s Unforgettable Firsthand Account by Colonel Robert Shaw. The title alone sparked my curiosity about an often-overlooked segment of World War II and promised a unique glimpse into the wartime experiences of the U.S. Army on Okinawa. However, while I appreciated its exploration of this critical piece of history, my reading experience was tinged with both admiration and some disappointment.
One of the main strengths of Shaw’s narrative is its focus on the underrepresented role of the U.S. Army in the Battle of Okinawa. The author passionately recounts the contributions of the 96th Infantry Division, weaving together thrilling accounts of heroism from a perspective that shines a light on the Army’s sacrifices. As Shaw shares stories of Medal of Honor-earning actions and the bravery behind the Distinguished Service Cross, I found myself captivated by the valor of these soldiers who often fade into the background of wartime stories dominated by Marine Corps narratives.
Shaw’s writing brings the chaotic atmosphere of battle to life, especially the relentless conditions of the Okinawa weather. The torrential rains and mud that bogged down vehicles painted a vivid picture of the challenges faced by soldiers. His depiction of artillery operations, where crews risked "cook-off" events with overheating gun barrels, echoed the harshness of that campaign. These elements made my heart race—I could almost feel the tension rising with each turn of the page.
However, the narrative is not without its issues. My initial enthusiasm waned as I noticed inconsistencies in the storytelling. Shaw presents the events as though he witnessed them firsthand, which felt somewhat misleading given his role as an artillery officer. The mixing up of military ranks and units also created a muddled understanding of the hierarchy and actions, taking me out of the immersive experience he tried to create.
Additionally, the author’s consistent use of full ranks and names for every individual mentioned was a stylistic choice that, while perhaps intended to provide clarity, often interrupted the flow. It made the prose feel stiff at times, detracting from the emotional weight of the narrative.
Ultimately, I felt this book could have been a solid 4-star read, but due to the issues with organization and narrative cohesion, I found myself landing on a 3-star rating. For those who have a keen interest in military history or want to learn more about the often overshadowed US Army contributions during WWII, this book certainly has value.
In conclusion, 82 Days on Okinawa is a mixed bag—it offers both powerful anecdotes filled with bravery and emotional depth while faltering in execution. For readers willing to overlook its shortcomings, there’s a heartfelt story waiting to unfold, one that poignantly captures the true spirit of those who fought valiantly, rain-soaked and weary, on Okinawa.
Discover more about 82 Days on Okinawa: One American's Unforgettable Firsth… on GoodReads >>
