A Missed Opportunity: A Personal Reflection on American Daughters
When I first stumbled upon American Daughters by Piper Huguley, I was immediately drawn to its premise—a historical novel exploring the friendship between Alice Roosevelt and Portia Washington amid the rigid backdrop of segregation. The idea itself was tantalizing, promising an engaging narrative revolving around two iconic figures from vastly different worlds. Yet, as I delved into the pages, I soon realized that the execution dwelled far from the heights I had hoped for.
The story alternates between the lives of Alice, Theodore Roosevelt’s spirited daughter, and Portia, daughter of Booker T. Washington. Their connection, albeit intriguing, seemed speculative, often burdened by insufficient historical evidence regarding Portia. I appreciated Huguley’s intentions, but I found the narrative faltering under an array of discrepancies.
From the outset, I encountered minor quibbles that set a somewhat skeptical tone for my reading journey. Anachronisms peppered the dialogue, as phrases and expressions slipped through that felt distinctly modern. It felt like a lack of historical care—a serious slip for a historical novel. For instance, a scene where young Congressman Nicholas Longworth approaches Alice with overtly flirtatious remarks came off not just as unrealistic but actively jarring. The societal norms of the era demanded a reserve, particularly from women of Alice’s standing, and seeing these standards disregarded felt disrespectful to the very fabric of the time.
Moreover, the alternating timelines of Alice and Portia could be disjointed, making me feel jumpy while trying to piece together their narratives. The storytelling occasionally leaned toward exposition rather than immersive scenes, depriving us of experiencing the emotional weight of key moments—like the heartbreaking abuse faced by Portia and her daughter.
While Alice’s characterization left something to be desired—at times seeming a bit vacant—Portia’s story drew me in more fully. Portia felt real and layered, and her struggles resonated with a raw authenticity that I wished Alice’s narrative could have matched. I found myself hoping for deeper explorations of their lives, for moments that might reconcile the deep friendship hinted at by history.
One poignant moment that stood out was when Alice visits Mrs. Coolidge after the tragic death of her son, delivering life-changing news of her own pregnancy amidst such grief. The dissonance in the scene was striking. Alice’s cheerful tidings seemed to trivialize profound sorrow, illustrating a disregard for emotional authenticity that echoed throughout the novel.
Despite my disappointment, I can see elements of American Daughters appealing to readers interested in historical fiction or those curious about the early 20th century. However, for those who appreciate meticulous historical accuracy and depth of character development, this might feel like a lackluster read.
As I closed the book, I couldn’t help but reflect on the vast potential that lay within its pages. Though it faltered on execution, it reminded me of the rich history that underpins narratives of friendship, breaking boundaries, and the complexities of human relationships. While American Daughters didn’t quite meet my expectations, it sparked a desire for more explorations of these fascinating figures—perhaps in a narrative yet to come.
Discover more about American Daughters on GoodReads >>
