A Journey Through Freedom: Reflecting on Freewater

When I first picked up Freewater, the latest Newbery Medal recipient by the talented author, I was drawn in by its premise—a story set amidst the historical refuge of the Great Big Swamp, a lesser-known sanctuary for runaway slaves. The promise of a narrative shedding light on such an overlooked slice of history felt juicy, alive with potential. However, as I washed over the pages, it became clear that this journey would turn from excitement to disappointment.

Exploring Themes and Characters

At its core, Freewater aims to weave a tapestry of hope, survival, and the quest for freedom, embodied by characters like Homer and Ada. Their journey reflects a youthful desperation to reunite with their mother from whom they’ve escaped. The emotional resonance here is powerful, and I did find myself sympathizing with their plight, particularly in moments where they express their longing and fear. As Homer observes, “I couldn’t go back. I couldn’t go back,” I felt the weight of uncertainty and the harsh truth of their reality.

However, underlying that emotional depth is a prominent gap. For all the idyllic images of children swinging through trees and foraging in a nearly magical wilderness, the portrayal of the brutality of enslavement often feels understated. There were glimpses of the horrors, but the overall atmosphere felt somewhat sanitized. I couldn’t shake the feeling that the characters, infused with modern sensibilities, lacked the authentic dialogue and mannerisms reflective of their historical context. This disconnect dulled the urgency of their struggles, making it easy to forget the heavy backdrop against which their story unfolds.

Narrative Flow and Style

While I appreciate the use of multiple perspectives to enrich a narrative, the execution in Freewater felt disjointed at times. Shifts between character viewpoints often left me momentarily puzzled, and the abrupt transitions sometimes disrupted the narrative flow. In particular, I found the first-person point of view for Homer contrasting jarringly with the third-person perspectives of others. It took me out of the story rather than drawing me in.

Moreover, while the picturesque refuge of Freewater could have offered a compelling counterpoint to the looming threat of slavery, it often felt less engaging. I found the pacing slow and, at times, tedious. As a reader, I yearned for more stakes, more tension. It was challenging to form a deep connection with the characters, friendships that failed to leave a mark, and moments that didn’t entirely resonate.

Memorable Words and Closing Thoughts

A notable quote, “You ever seen something that don’t seem real? I’ve seen a few things,” lingers in my mind. It embodies both the magic of a child’s perspective and the harrowing realities they face. Yet, in Freewater, that blend of reality with fantasy never quite hits the balance.

In the end, while I acknowledge that Freewater has interesting concepts and themes tied to strength, survival, and freedom, it didn’t resonate with me as I had hoped it would. Perhaps younger readers or those more attuned to magical realism may find joy in its pages. For me, it was a bittersweet disappointment—one which left me wishing for a deeper engagement with both the characters and the history they inhabit.

If you’re seeking a book that tackles themes of freedom and childhood innocence, perhaps give Freewater a chance. Just remember, this journey varies greatly depending on where you’re standing. Here’s hoping for a more fulfilling expedition in next year’s Newbery winner!

Discover more about Freewater on GoodReads >>