Review of Taking Manhattan: The Extraordinary Events That Created… by Russell Shorto
When I first came across Taking Manhattan: The Extraordinary Events That Created… by Russell Shorto, I felt a spark of curiosity. As someone who has always been enchanted by New York City’s vibrant tapestry of cultures and histories, the idea of exploring its lesser-known Dutch origins thrilled me. Shorto’s reputation for blending meticulous research with engaging prose made this book a must-read for me.
In Taking Manhattan, Shorto dives deep into the early days of New York, originally known as New Amsterdam, revealing how the city’s identity as a global trade hub took shape. Traditionally overshadowed by English narratives, the Dutch presence is illuminated here as a critical facet of the area’s history—a narrative that often goes untold. One of the most fascinating aspects is the contrast Shorto draws between New Amsterdam and its neighboring colonies, particularly Boston. The welcoming nature of New Amsterdam, which embraced diverse peoples, colors, and religions, starkly contrasts with Boston’s more Puritanical backdrop.
I found the characters in this historical narrative compelling—particularly Peter Stuyvesant, the formidable governor of Dutch New Amsterdam, and Richard Nicoll, the English representative of the Duke of York. Their unlikely showdown is a surprising highlight, especially in how it played out peacefully, defying the violent norms of colonial territorial conflict. This moment, delicately captured by Shorto, breathes life into history, making it relatable and digestible, even for readers who might not typically gravitate towards historical texts.
Shorto’s writing style truly shines throughout the book. His deft ability to weave in anecdotes alongside rich historical analysis keeps the pacing brisk and engaging. I particularly enjoyed how he navigated the complex legacy of the Dutch—while they were more inclusive in some ways, they also laid the groundwork for detrimental practices like slavery, which we’re still grappling with today. His thoughtful examination of these contrasting legacies resonated with me deeply, reminding me of our ongoing struggle with historical narratives.
One of the standout moments in Taking Manhattan comes from Shorto’s reflections on irony. The passage where he discusses the marriage of James II’s daughter to the Dutch Willem of Orange—and how it culminated in the unlikely ascension of William and Mary on the English throne—made me chuckle. History has a way of circling back on itself in amusing and profound ways, doesn’t it?
If you’re a history enthusiast, a New Yorker at heart, or simply someone who enjoys narratives rich with detail and depth, Taking Manhattan is undoubtedly for you. Shorto not only expands our understanding of New York’s past but also invites us to reflect on its lasting impact today. As I closed the book, I found myself not just more informed, but inspired to appreciate the diversity that makes this city so unique.
In essence, my reading experience with Taking Manhattan was both enlightening and enriching. It’s a testament to the beauty of storytelling, proving that even the most overlooked chapters of history can resonate powerfully with our present. I can’t recommend it enough!
Discover more about Taking Manhattan: The Extraordinary Events That Created… on GoodReads >>
