A Dance Through History: A Review of The Swans of Harlem: Five Black Ballerinas, Fifty Years by Karen Valby
When I first picked up The Swans of Harlem, I knew I was in for a journey that extended well beyond the confines of classical ballet. Karen Valby’s dedication to resurrecting the stories of the trailblazing Black ballerinas of the Dance Theatre of Harlem (DTH) struck a chord with me. Like many, I had been under the impression that Misty Copeland was the first Black ballerina to achieve stardom, but Valby’s illuminating narrative quickly clears the air, reminding us that history is often more complex—and beautiful—than it seems.
Valby’s exploration of the lives of Lydia Abarca, Gayle McKinney-Griffith, Sheila Rohan, Karlya Shelton, and Marcia Sells is not merely a celebration of their achievements; it’s an act of unearthing the cultural and personal struggles faced by Black dancers in a field that historically sidelined them. These women faced immense challenges, yet each embraced the power of their art with unwavering determination. I found myself particularly moved by Gayle McKinney-Griffith’s journey from a discouraged Juilliard student to a celebrated ballerina, highlighting the resilience that defines the spirit of DTH.
One of the key themes that resonated within Valby’s prose is the idea of legacy and recognition. The formation of the ‘152nd Street Black Ballet Legacy Council’ during the isolating pandemic illustrates the strength of community amidst adversity. Their weekly meetings served as a vital anchor, bringing together stories and experiences that had long been hidden or forgotten. This sense of sisterhood fostered by shared experience is palpable throughout the book—each dancer’s narrative intertwines in a way that feels both intimate and universal.
Valby’s writing style is engaging and sharply insightful; she expertly captures both the triumphs and tribulations of these dancers with sensitivity. The pacing allows the reader to fully absorb the rich tapestry of their stories while feeling the emotional weight of their histories. I enjoyed her use of vivid imagery and poignant quotes drawn from the dancers themselves. For example, when one ballerina reflects, “You know how they talk about planting seeds? Arthur Mitchell planted a seed in me,” I felt the heartfelt significance of mentorship and growth leap off the pages.
What truly makes The Swans of Harlem compelling, however, is its dual function as both a historical document and a source of inspiration. Valby makes a powerful case for the importance of honoring these women and their contributions to ballet, particularly in a cultural moment where visibility—especially for Black women in the arts—is crucial.
I would highly recommend this book not only to aficionados of ballet but also to those who appreciate stories of resilience, identity, and the intertwining of art and social justice. Valby’s heartfelt tribute will resonate with anyone looking for representation or inspiration in the arts. Personally, this read prompted me to reflect on the importance of affirming diverse voices in all fields and left me with a deeper appreciation for the art form I thought I understood.
Against the backdrop of ballet’s elegance, The Swans of Harlem serves as a reminder that behind every pirouette and arabesque lies a story worth telling. Thank you, Karen Valby, for bringing these remarkable women’s legacies back into the spotlight.
Be sure to follow along for more bookish musings at Barb’s Reviews.
Discover more about The Swans of Harlem: Five Black Ballerinas, Fifty Years… on GoodReads >>
